People who know me always make the comment that I’ve been “gay from the womb.” They’re right. I have been. I can’t ever remember a time when my sexual orientation was different than it is now. There’s been a lot of discussion about whether being gay is about sexual preference or sexual orientation. I’m a firm believer that it’s about orientation and just about everyone else is on board with that. In fact, in 1986, the American Psychiatric Association removed homosexuality from the DSM.
So, when a few people asked how I knew that early on, I decided to write this. The answer is that I didn’t know that I was gay from that early on. What I did know is that I was different, but I didn’t have a name for it. Let’s face it, we’re talking the very early sixties when I had my first experience. Nobody was really talking about it then and, if you were doing it, you were doing it in the closet. Contrary to popular belief, it was not a comfortable time to be gay. That was one of the things I find surprising about the sixties. In spite of the incredible openness of the time, being gay was risky. It was the decade of free love as long as it was heterosexual love. Finally, keep in mind that all of my experiences happened in the context of going to Catholic school. I did that right up through college.
My first experience was just like what other kids were doing: Playing “doctor.” Except my girlfriends were doing it with boys. Not me! Wasn’t the least bit interested in the male anatomy. Literally couldn’t be bothered. Boys were for playing hockey and baseball with. I’m still pretty much in that zone at the age of fifty-five. Nothing has changed. When it comes to men, my friends call me the “oldest living virgin.” Never the twain shall meet. I certainly don’t feel like I’ve missed anything.
Of course, there are plenty of people who just don’t “get it.” I’ve been asked countless times how I know I don’t like sex with men if I’ve never tried it. Listen, people, if it doesn’t interest you, there’s no point in trying it. That’s why I’m adamant about the fact that being gay is all about orientation, not try it and see.
Mmmmmm…something sure is different about me
The first time I had a feeling that I was different was as early as grammar school, and I’m thinking it had to be somewhere between the sixth and the eighth grades (or around the time we started going to dances). Most of my girlfriends were standing around looking at the boys. I, on the other hand, was standing around looking at the girls. However, it wasn’t that I didn’t hang out with boys. In fact, I had a blast with the boys…playing street hockey and baseball. My best friend was a boy. His name was Greg, and we had the best time together, but there was nada in the way of physical attraction. Of course, back then, what I didn’t realize was that we were both gay. As we got older, this turned into a great advantage because our families thought we were going out together. It certainly kept the heat off.
By high school, it was apparent that I was far from being like everyone else. The good thing was that I wasn’t alone anymore. There were five or six of us at Arlington Catholic who knew, by that time, that we were gay. That didn’t make it any easier to be gay, however. We were definitely singled out for ridicule by the other students. It was tough going initially. We eventually went from ridicule to novelty and life became easier. We all went to the prom together, with dates (albeit other gay people). The guy I went with was a riot. We had a blast at the prom, and the next day we all headed down to P-Town for the day, while the rest of our classmates went to Hyannis.
During my senior year, I also had my first fairly serious relationship. I’ve written about this already on this blog. It was with Linda, a girl who had been my constant companion since grammar school. I remember we started writing love letters to each other. For some reason my mother became suspicious of us, and began to go through my bureau drawers in search of evidence. She found it and proceeded to freak out. However, I had already learned that all you had to do was tell my mother what she wanted to hear and things would calm down. I did just that, and the freak out passed. The relationship lasted about a year (she was younger than me). By the time I moved on to Aquinas, it was over. She eventually married a guy named Mark and had five children.
That would not, however, be my fate.
The lesbian playground
I moved on to Aquinas Junior College in Newton. It may well have been a Catholic school, but it was a hotbed of lesbian relationships…my own included. I had a great group of friends and I would become involved intimately with two of them, one casual and one fairly serious. The casual relationship is indicative of the way some people thought back then. With Karen, you could kiss, but never go any further. It was almost as though that kept her from admitting she was a lesbian. There’s no question that it was tough coming out.
My relationship with Mary was much more serious. The reality was that I was also attracted to her younger sister, Barbara, but she turned out to be just a good friend. Mary and I moved in together after graduation, living in an apartment building owned by my brother-in-law and his family. She worked at Tufts Medical Center in Boston as a medical secretary and I worked at Millipore Corporation as a secretary to the promotion department.
While we were not closeted with our friends, we were definitely closeted with
our families. She came from a strong Irish Catholic background and I came from an Italian Catholic background. There was no way we could comfortably come out of the closet at the age of twenty-one. The pressure to marry was incredible, but I had the courage of my convictions and my family eventually backed off. Not hers. Her uncle was a Catholic priest and really put the pressure on her. The relationship was doomed after that. As fate would have it, her uncle would turn out to be one of the most prolific pedophile priests ever seen in the Archdiocese of Boston. The Catholic church would eventually end up settling more than seventeen separate allegations. If that isn’t a case of the pot calling the kettle black, nothing is. I walked away from the Catholic church for good after that experience.
After my relationship with Mary ended, I moved back home for a while. However, the whole experience of having nearly been outed to my family by a pedophile priest only galvanized my desire to live my life the way I was meant to live it. I couldn’t do that while living at home. That’s when I moved to Melrose and my life as a lesbian really took off.
Comfortable with who I am
I think that I’ve been comfortable as a lesbian for many years, but it wasn’t always so. Anyone who tells you that they do not — at one time or another — long to be like everyone else is a liar. I went through that for a short period of time after my relationship with Mary. It just seemed too hard to be who I was. During my two years at Aquinas, I had lost contact with Greg. After graduation, we renewed our friendship. He was out of the closet. I was out of the closet. The party had begun.
Within a year of breaking up with Mary, a year in which I questioned who and what I was…and what I wanted to be, a great weight was finally lifted off my shoulders. It was Greg’s friendship that helped me get to that point in my life. I’ve been there ever since.
I came out because, once you do that, everything gets easier. That’s not to say you don’t lose some people along the way. I did. However, I determined that if my sexual orientation was the breaking point of a friendship, it wasn’t really a friendship to begin with. What it did for me was remove the unknown fears that had been preying on my emotions. It allowed me to face reality and assess where my life was. While it hurt that some people turned their backs on me, it also took a huge weight off my shoulders. The older I got, the harder it became to pretend to be what I wasn’t.
I came out at Millipore as well. I decided to do that because I spent a considerable part of every day there. While several people had advised against doing that, I found few repercussions. In fact, I discovered that Millipore was a pretty progressive company back in the mid-to-late seventies. Again, I lost a couple of friends, but that was just about all the trouble I would have.
Speaking personally, I carry the LGBT flag proudly. None of us has anything to be ashamed of. If we’re ashamed of ourselves, then it gives everyone else permission to be ashamed of us. If we stay hidden, then they can keep us hidden. All we can do is speak our truth regardless of the repercussions because, at the end of the day, all we have left is our integrity. I am out everywhere now, at work, at home, with all my friends and foes. Doesn’t matter. My attitude now is, if you’ve got a problem with who I am, it’s your problem.